אינהאַלט אויסגעמעקט אינהאַלט צוגעלייגט
שורה 23:
:::Although I agree with you that creating stub articles isn’t a violation and shouldn’t be deleted, I must also agree with Kuzia. Kuzia doesn’t have an issue with you personally. Kuzia explained it very clear above and I strongly agree with that. The main point here is that all articles which are important for the Yiddish Wikipedia, like biography articles of Jews, Judaism subjects, Jewish history, Jewish areas, and Yiddish language history and usage, all these should be kept even if they are stubs and wrong but instead we should try and work to improve them. But articles that have no importance in a Wikipedia in Yiddish (as you may notice the fact that no one bothered writing these articles here during the past 10 years), no one is really interested in reading these articles in the Yiddish language, so if it is extremely short and wrongly written, I don’t see any reason not to delete it. Of course anyone can add any articles they like, but at least it has to be whole and correct ([[באַניצער:עולםגולם|עולםגולם]] ([[באַניצער רעדן:עולםגולם|רעדן]]) 15:55, 18 פעברואר 2016 (UTC))
 
:::: @לאג_ראיל I have very little to add to the words of עולםגולם. First, you misunderstood my nominations, Poylisher's message to me and my response. I am not going to translate them to you. Second, we have already had a [[באַניצער רעדן:לאג רעיל#די שפּראַך|nice conversation]] about Yiddish before: Yiddish is certainly not what you think it is. I see no reason why Yiddish wikipedia must be any different from wikipedias in other languages: if I go now to Turkish wikipedia and write an article about some Jewish scientist one sentence long using Google Translate I shouldn't be surprised if it gets deleted within an hour. Third, no I don't use any translator, if you don't understand what I write, this is your personal problem: my writing deviates from literary Yiddish only in the dialectal markings, which everyone here is free to express. And last: you reversed the nominations without providing any reason which is a violation of the wikipedia rules. The only way of proceeding in this situation is to either improve the articles yourself or ask Peylisher to do that for you, otherwise I will insist on deleting them. Thanks. [[באַניצער:Kuzia|הר ורדים]] ([[באַניצער רעדן:Kuzia|רעדן]]) 16:55, 18 פעברואר 2016 (UTC)
 
</div>